Sabato's Crystal Ball

2012 Presidential Possibilities, ranked by likelihood to win GOP nomination

Updated Jan. 23, 2011

Candidate Key Advantages Key Disadvantages
Mitt Romney
Former MA Gov.
•Business background in bad economy
•Looks the part
•Weak field
•Good fundraiser, been around the track
•Blue state strengths (MI, NH)
•Romneycare
•Conservatives skeptical of him
•Flip-flops
•Religion
•Minimal frontrunner
•Inability to break through his low ceiling
Rick Santorum
Former PA Sen.
•DC elective experience
•Strong social issue conservative
•Iowa appeal
•Lost own Senate seat by 17%
•Too conservative for general election
Newt Gingrich
Ex-House Speaker
•100% Name ID
•Eloquent speaker
•Admired by GOP base
•Presidential-level GOP experience
•Polarizer
•Unlikely to win in November
•Personal baggage
•Prickly persona
Ron Paul
TX Congressman
•Intense support among slice of GOP & Independents
•Medium name recognition
•Views on some subjects (such as Iraq) outside GOP mainstream
•Advanced age, prior losses

Recent President Analysis

The Long Slog: Projecting the Republican Race Through June

Had evangelical Christians had their way in 2006’s Pennsylvania Senate election, then-Sen. Rick Santorum (R) would have been reelected in a landslide: among the quarter of the electorate that identified themselves as such, Santorum won 59% to 41%. The trouble for Santorum was that, of the non-evangelical three-fourths of the electorate, Santorum lost to his [...]

Romney Tries to Match a Rare Feat

, Political Analyst

Correction: This article originally omitted James K. Polk, who won the presidency in 1844 despite losing his home state of Tennessee by 0.1 percentage points to Henry Clay.
If Mitt Romney wins the nomination, he may face an uphill battle in winning the presidency because of an obscure historical oddity: Presidents who lose their home state [...]

A Tale of a Tweet

, Director, U.Va. Center for Politics

Twitter is a perfect medium for the age of short attention spans. With a limit of 140 characters per tweet, one can’t say anything especially nuanced — though it is true that short phrases like “I love you” and “We declare war” have great power.
Despite its limitations, every now and then a tweet can cause [...]

Video: Nothing’s Easy for Romney

, Director, U.Va. Center for Politics

Just how bad were Tuesday night’s primary and caucus results for Mitt Romney? And is Rick Santorum now his top challenger? Center for Politics Director Larry J. Sabato breaks down Santorum’s unexpected sweep and what it all means in our latest Crystal Ball video. Check it out for a look ahead to the future Republican [...]

The Third Party Illusion

, Senior Columnist

If you’ve been following the political commentary in the national media recently, you’ve probably heard that the 2012 presidential election is likely to result in the largest vote for a third party candidate in many years, perhaps exceeding the 19% of the national popular vote won by Ross Perot in 1992. According to a number [...]

How Long Is Romney’s Road to the Nomination?

, U.Va. Center for Politics

The moon over Miami was a blue moon for Newt, a bad moon rising for Gingrich. This moon’s shine was all for Mitt Romney, illuminating a moon river that seems set to eventually carry Romney to the Republican presidential nomination.
But how fast is “eventually?” In this roller coaster race, no one should pretend to know [...]

Update: Unemployment and the Presidential Race

, Political Analyst, U.Va. Center for Politics

Back in September, the Crystal Ball examined the possible electoral impact of state-by-state unemployment figures because, after all, presidents are elected in 51 individual battles (50 states plus Washington, D.C.)
With the January jobs report to be released this Friday, we thought we would once again examine the state-by-state numbers, which are shown in Chart 1. [...]

The Iowa Reversal

, Senior Columnist

Note: This article is cross-posted from Rhodes Cook’s political blog.
Up and down and all around the 2012 Republican presidential campaign has gone. It has probably been the craziest nominating race in the last generation.
And from this vantage point, the weirdest event of all thus far was the changing outcome in Iowa – from an 8-vote [...]

The Republicans’ Electoral College Newt-Mare

, U.Va. Center for Politics

What can we expect from the Florida primary? What are the possible repercussions of a Gingrich victory versus those of a Romney win in the Sunshine State? Check out our latest Crystal Ball video by clicking on the picture. Below, we examine the Republican electoral situation and what a Gingrich candidacy might mean:

In the aftermath [...]

Do Endorsements Matter?

, Director, U.Va. Center for Politics

Note: This article originally appeared in the Jan. 24 edition of The Wall Street Journal.
Do endorsements matter? Politicians certainly think so, and they spend loads of time courting party elites and opinion-makers. So far, though, 2012 has shown how the politics of anointment and appointment can fail.
South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley flopped mightily in trying [...]

Romney’s Coronation: Just Delayed, or Gone Awry?

, U.Va. Center for Politics

This much is obvious: South Carolina has proven to be a disaster for Mitt Romney. The size of his defeat by Newt Gingrich — a 12%+ landslide in a four-way race — is virtually a repudiation of his candidacy in a state that has prided itself on picking the eventual nominee for 32 years. And [...]

Romney’s Opponents Look for the Spirit Of ‘76

, Political Analyst, U.Va. Center for Politics

While Mitt Romney may very well be on his way to winning the GOP nomination, he is not completely out of the woods yet. With so many primaries and caucuses left to be decided, it is perfectly possible that other candidates will win some of the remaining states as long as they stay in the [...]

Ten Days to Stop Romney

, U.Va. Center for Politics

Is Mitt Romney unstoppable? Will South Carolina risk its perfect primary record to back someone else? And will Ron Paul go all the way to the convention? Get our take — and answers to your Twitter questions — in our latest Crystal Ball video. Analysis of New Hampshire and a look ahead to South Carolina [...]

Notes on the State of Politics

Modern Cabinets: No “Team of Rivals”
With Mitt Romney leading in the Republican nomination battle, there has been talk of what kind of roles the other GOP candidates might occupy in a hypothetical Romney administration. Naturally, the first position discussed is vice president, but there has also been talk of Cabinet appointments, and it is [...]

On to New Hampshire

What a night! Tuesday night’s Iowa caucuses got the Republican primary season off to a rousing start, with Mitt Romney winning the narrowest of victories over Rick Santorum.
What do the Iowa results mean, and what should we expect in New Hampshire? Check out our first-ever Crystal Ball video to get our take. And with next [...]